NHSE rejects claim Mackey supported surgeon linked to patient harm

NHS England has said claims chief executive Sir Jim Mackey supported a surgeon linked with cases of avoidable harm are ‘categorically untrue’.

Sir Jim Mackey © Newcastle Upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust

Sir Jim Mackey © Newcastle Upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust

The firm rejection came after the BBC reported that during a meeting in 2024 when Sir Jim was chief executive of the Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust he had recommended Karen Booth being able to resume her surgical career.

An NHSE spokesperson said: ‘This claim is categorically untrue. At the meeting in question in 2024, Jim set out how the trust was supporting its employee – following the findings of independent reviews and through an ongoing investigation by the GMC – and the steps required before they could practice independently again.

‘He did not say he was in support of the employee resuming their surgical career – that is a matter for the GMC's investigation – and the employee did not return to operating during Jim's tenure and is still not operating in the meantime.'

Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust has apologised for the failings.

The trust said a referral had been made to the GMC, adding the consultant was at the first stage of a structured return to work at a different hospital trust.

'Culture of fear' found at trust rated requires improvement

'Culture of fear' found at trust rated requires improvement

By Lee Peart 16 July 2026

A ‘culture of fear’ has been found at King’s College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust.

Trust introduces Martha's Rule to strengthen patient safety

By Lee Peart 14 July 2026

Doncaster and Bassetlaw Teaching Hospitals (DBTH) has introduced Martha’s Rule across its hospitals.

Doctor caused severe clinical harm to patients, review finds

By Lee Peart 10 July 2026

A doctor at St Helier Hospital in Surrey caused severe clinical harm to patients with interstitial lung disease (ILD), a review has found.


Popular articles by Lee Peart