The literature review, published in the Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, found scant evidence ACPs can replace doctors when diagnosing and treating patients with complex conditions or symptoms where the cause is not yet known.
Dr Jatinder Hayre, public health researcher and honorary fellow at the University of Leicester, said: ‘Advanced Clinical Practitioners can make an important contribution to patient care, but contribution should not be confused with substitution. Our review found that the expansion of these roles has moved faster than the evidence needed to show that replacing doctors delivers the same standards of diagnosis, patient safety and cost-effectiveness.
‘Some studies we looked at as part of this identified important differences in areas such as investigations, prescribing, referrals and the use of other healthcare services. This does not mean ACPs cannot provide safe and effective care, but it does mean we need much stronger evidence before assuming they can replace doctors across increasingly complex areas of medicine.
‘Ultimately, this is about making sure workforce changes are driven not simply by the need to fill gaps, but by evidence about what provides the safest and most effective care for patients.
‘At present, there is no convincing evidence that ACPs can substitute medical doctors without compromising patient-safety and the health service. An immediate halt of recruitment of ACPs and urgent review of expansion is needed.'
