Only just begun

Angharad Hughes, partner in the clinical negligence department at JMW Solicitors, says Martha's Rule was built for safety; its impact on birth injury claims is only beginning

Angharad Hughes (c) JMW Solicitors

Angharad Hughes (c) JMW Solicitors

Martha's Rule was introduced to give patients, families and NHS staff another route to raise the alarm when they believe somebody's condition is deteriorating and their concerns are not being acted upon. The numbers already show how significant that route has become. NHS England recorded 16,160 calls under Martha's Rule between September 2024 and May 2026.

There is another consequence of Martha's Rule that will take much longer to become visible.

For most people, Martha's Rule is a patient-safety story. As a clinical negligence solicitor who acts for families following a wide range of injuries, I also see something else in it: the emergence of a formal record showing that a patient or family raised a concern at a particular point in their care and asked for it to be reviewed.

The important question is whether concerns are heard, independently assessed and acted upon appropriately.

Why birth injury cases may look different in future

Martha's Rule principles have particular relevance to maternity care, where changes observed or experienced can form an important part of the overall clinical picture.

One issue that repeatedly arises in maternity cases is whether a woman expressed concern about a change in her condition and, if she did, how clinicians responded. An expectant mother might remember reporting changes, but the clinical record may not document that conversation in the same terms, or at all. Years later, establishing what was said, when it was said and what happened next can become difficult.

This is where Martha's Rule has the potential to have an impact.

A formal escalation creates a notable point at which the concern was raised and a process should have followed it. It does not prove that negligent care occurred.

What it can do is reduce uncertainty about one important factual question: was a concern raised? And, in cases where there is a documented escalation, the argument may increasingly move on to a different question: what happened in response?

The three horizons of Martha's Rule

I think we are likely to see the longer-term impact of Martha's Rule emerge in three stages.

The first is visibility and it is happening now. Concerns that might previously have been expressed informally at a bedside can increasingly become identifiable events within a patient's care.

The second horizon will come when litigation catches up with the change. Over the next few years, however, it may be that we see evidence in individual's medical records as to when a request under Martha's Rule has been made and the response to this.

The third horizon is potentially the most important: the quality of the response itself becomes the focus. If it is accepted that a concern was raised, scrutiny will inevitably move towards what happened afterwards. Who carried out the review? How quickly did it happen? And, crucially, did the escalation make any meaningful difference to the patient's care? These are questions that hospitals will increasingly have to be able to answer within their own records of a response to an escalation under Martha's rule.

What could this mean for maternity care?

The underlying principle behind Martha's Rule is straightforward: concerns about deterioration should be listened to and there should be a clear route to escalate them when someone does not believe they are being adequately addressed.

There can also be circumstances in which a patient remains concerned despite having already spoken to the clinical team.

Martha's Rule is not a substitute for speaking to midwives and doctors, using existing maternity escalation processes or seeking urgent medical attention when it is required. Its importance lies in the broader principle that patients and families should have another route when they remain concerned that deterioration is not being recognised.

May figures demonstrate just how frequently families are already using that opportunity in the hospital settings. Of the 16,160 calls recorded by NHS England, 72% came through the family and carer escalation process.

The important question as the programme develops will be whether the same principle can become embedded effectively within maternity and neonatal care.

The meaning behind the call numbers

The NHS England numbers are important, but the longer-term measure of Martha's Rule will be more complicated.

It will be whether the reviews that follow are sufficiently prompt and independent. Whether clinicians are given the resources and authority to respond properly. And whether the system consistently identifies deterioration that might otherwise have been missed.

When the first generation of clinical negligence claims involving Martha's Rule begins to work its way through the legal system, we will be able to see whether the existence of a formal escalation record becomes key evidence in these cases.

 

The NHS's digital ambition depends on resilience first

The NHS's digital ambition depends on resilience first

19 November 2026

Martin Bradbury, regional vice-president UKI, Dynatrace says digital resilience should no longer be a concern confined to IT, it needs to be a priority focus...

UNISON launches four days of strike action at Northern Care Alliance

By Lee Peart 19 November 2026

Four days of strike action running on 18, 23, 24 and 27 November have been launched by UNISON members at four hospitals run by Northern Care Alliance.

House of Lords urges action to reverse decline in childhood vaccination

By Lee Peart 19 November 2026

A House of Lords special inquiry committee has called for Government action to reverse the decline in childhood vaccination.