NHS faces further significant costs following Supreme Court ruling

A Supreme Court judgement could have significant cost implications for the NHS.

(c) Tingey Injury Law Firm/Unsplash

(c) Tingey Injury Law Firm/Unsplash

In its ruling yesterday, the Supreme Court allowed a clinical negligence claim for ‘lost years' damages against Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHSFT.

The claimant suffered a severe brain injury as a consequence of hypoxia during her birth in 2015 and has been entirely dependent on others since the time of her birth with no prospect of improvement. Her life expectancy is agreed to be 29.

Kennedys Law LLP said: ‘There is no doubt this judgment will have a significant financial impact on insurers managing catastrophic injury claims involving children. Of greater impact will be on NHS Resolution who manage birth injury related claims in the NHS.' 

An NHS Resolution spokesperson said: ‘The Supreme Court has handed down its judgment in the case of CCC v Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHSFT. The court's judgment has provided important clarification about the law around compensation for "lost years" in clinical negligence cases, and how such losses are to be calculated. We will carefully consider the ruling and its implications for our work in compensation claims which involve the NHS.'

Jane McNicholas, chief medical officer, Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHSFT, said: ‘Following the birth of this child in 2015 we carried out a full review of what happened and there were clearly aspects of the care which should have been done differently, and we are so very sorry that this happened.

‘We apologised unreservedly to the family and have made significant changes since then to how we monitor women in labour in line with NICE guidance and NHS Resolution maternity standards. We now also have annual foetal monitoring training in place for all our midwives and medical staff which is informed by national and local learning and guidance.'

NHS diagnoses 1,000 cancers a day for first time

NHS diagnoses 1,000 cancers a day for first time

By Lee Peart 05 November 2026

The NHS diagnosed over 1,000 cancers a day for the first time in 2024, according to the latest NHSE statistics.

BREAKING NEWS: Five-year settlement rights given to health and care workers

By Lee Peart 02 November 2026

Care workers earning £25,000 and doctors and nurses will be given settlement rights after five years under reforms announced by the home secretary.

Keeping AI accountable

02 November 2026

Beth Miller, global field CISO, Mimecast, discusses accountability when AI touches patient care


Popular articles by Lee Peart