Draft document to prioritise patients during Covid revealed at inquiry

A draft document prioritising patients for treatment in the event of services being overwhelmed was drawn up during Covid, an NHS leader has revealed.

Professor Sir Stephen Powis (c) Hemming Group

Professor Sir Stephen Powis (c) Hemming Group

National medical director of NHS England, Professor Sir Stephen Powis, shared details of the ‘decision-making tool' during evidence to the Covid-19 Inquiry yesterday.

Prof Powis said: ‘Frankly, I was personally terrified, that the NHS was going to be overwhelmed and doctors were going to be placed in a position, and other clinicians, where they would not be able to make the professional judgment that they usually make in terms of treatments and escalation.

‘And in those circumstances, as I had said to the Health Select Committee earlier in March, we and -- I and my clinical colleagues, the CMOs, felt that we should begin to explore a decision tool such as this.'

The decision tool assigned points to patients based on a patient's age, frailty and underlying conditions with those with high scores being excluded from intensive care.

Prof Powis said the plans were dropped on 28 March 2020 when the peak of the pandemic was approaching and therefore it ‘was becoming increasingly clear to me that the peak of the pandemic was approaching and therefore it would not be needed because we would not breach capacity'.

The national medical director said there was a danger the tool ‘could have been used inappropriately', adding: ‘my recommendation to the Inquiry is that we should absolutely in future not try and develop one of these tools in the midst of a pandemic. This is a discussion that has to occur in normal times'.

THE BIG INTERVIEW: Speaking with one voice

THE BIG INTERVIEW: Speaking with one voice

By Lee Peart 17 July 2026

With this year’s passage of the Health Bill and ongoing implementation of the 10-Year Health Plan, chair of The NHS Alliance, Lord Adebowale, says there has ...

How the humble appraisal could unlock NHS-wide transformation

16 July 2026

Dr Patrick Doyle, consultant anaesthetist at Imperial College Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust and Founder of L2P (acquired by Patchwork Health), says the ann...

'Culture of fear' found at trust rated requires improvement

By Lee Peart 16 July 2026

A ‘culture of fear’ has been found at King’s College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust.


Popular articles by Lee Peart