Chancellor urged to tackle soaring cost of clinical negligence claims

Chancellor Rachel Reeves has been urged to tackle the soaring cost of clinical negligence claims in Wednesday’s Budget.

Dr Matthew Lee (c) Medical Defence Union

Dr Matthew Lee (c) Medical Defence Union

The call came in an open letter to the chancellor from the Medical Defence Union (MDU).

Dr Matthew Lee, chief executive of the MDU said: ‘The MDU has been sounding the alarm bell on the cost of clinical negligence for years, particularly around rising legal costs. We've written to the chancellor because the Budget offers a real opportunity for this Government to take decisive action and halt the eye-watering sums the NHS is paying out in legal fees.'

The NHS spent more than £800m on legal fees relating to clinical negligence claims in the last year, with £620m paid to claimant lawyers. The legal fees for lower-value claims were almost four times higher than the compensation awarded.

Dr Lee said: ‘Those harmed by negligence must receive appropriate compensation, however, it cannot be right for legal costs to far outweigh these awards. Action needs to be taken to keep this money within the NHS to support patient care and frontline services, which is what the UK taxpayer expects.'

The MDU's letter stressed the need to introduce Fixed Recoverable Costs (FRC) for lower-value claims, which could save over £50m a year. The scheme was due to be implemented in April 2024 but has been stalled due to ‘outstanding issues'.

In addition, the MDU called on the Government to publish David Lock KC's review into clinical medical negligence claims and urged it to amend Section 2(4) of the Law Reform (Personal Injuries) Act 1948, which requires courts to calculate compensation based on private healthcare costs rather than NHS provision. If claimants then choose to receive restorative treatment on the NHS, it can result in the health service effectively paying twice.

A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said: ‘We are very concerned about the rising costs of clinical negligence which is why we have asked David Lock KC to provide expert advice on how we can improve the system.

‘Our 10-Year Health Plan also makes clear that patient safety is the bedrock of a healthy NHS and we are committed to reducing the incidents of harm which can lead to claims.'

GPS
GPs urge Streeting to commit to train, recruit and retain numbers needed to deliver safe care

GPs urge Streeting to commit to train, recruit and retain numbers needed to deliver safe care

By Liz Wells 24 November 2025

The Royal College of GPs is warning that decades of chronic underfunding have left GP practices struggling to increase their GPs numbers, even as patient num...

NHS maintained almost all care for patients during doctors' strike

By Liz Wells 24 November 2025

The NHS managed to keep more than 95% of planned elective activity going ahead during recent strike action by resident doctors, surpassing the 93% protected ...

The complexity of Ambient AI

24 November 2025

How is ambient AI transforming frontline healthcare in the UK?, asks Simon Croll, technology lead at Phoenix Software


Popular articles by Lee Peart